Add Rockchip u-boot "binman" BOOT_SCENARIO (#7505)

* rockchip64: add `BOOT_SCENARIO=binman` for mainline u-boot

- drop special handling for 3308's `legacy` branch
- rpardini: note how SPI/mtd is not yet supported for this scenario

Co-authored-by: Ricardo Pardini <ricardo@pardini.net> (squash/splits, shellfmt)

* `rock-s0`/`rockpi-s`: use `BOOT_SCENARIO=binman`; move blobs to armbian/rkbin

- Move rk3308 boot blobs to armbian/rkbin
  - delete obsolete ones
- Alter rock-s0 and rockpi-s to use the new "binman" BOOT_SCENARIO

Co-authored-by: Ricardo Pardini <ricardo@pardini.net> (shellfmt; small fixes; squashes)

config/boards/rock-s0.conf

@@ -1,13 +1,32 @@
 # Rockchip RK3308 quad core 512MB SoC WiFi
 # https://radxa.com/products/rocks/s0
 
-# This board is very similar to the older RockPi-S model
-source "${SRC}/config/boards/rockpi-s.conf"
-
 BOARD_NAME="Rock S0"
-BOARD_MAINTAINER="brentr"
+BOARDFAMILY=rockchip64
-BOARDFAMILY="rockchip64"
+BOARD_MAINTAINER=brentr
-BOOTCONFIG="rock-s0-rk3308_defconfig"
+
-BOOT_FDT_FILE="rockchip/rk3308-rock-s0.dtb"
+BOOTCONFIG=rock-s0-rk3308_defconfig
-KERNEL_TARGET="current,edge"
+BOOT_FDT_FILE=rockchip/rk3308-rock-s0.dtb
-KERNEL_TEST_TARGET="current"
+
+KERNEL_TARGET=current,edge
+KERNEL_TEST_TARGET=current
+
+DEFAULT_CONSOLE=serial
+SERIALCON=ttyS0
+MODULES_BLACKLIST="rockchipdrm analogix_dp dw_mipi_dsi dw_hdmi gpu_sched lima hantro_vpu panfrost"
+HAS_VIDEO_OUTPUT=no
+
+BOOTBRANCH_BOARD=tag:v2024.10
+BOOTPATCHDIR=v2024.10
+BOOT_SCENARIO=binman
+DDR_BLOB=rk33/rk3308_ddr_589MHz_uart0_m0_v2.07.bin
+BL31_BLOB=rk33/rk3308_bl31_v2.26.elf
+
+OVERLAY_PREFIX=rk3308
+
+function post_family_config__rocks0() {
+	declare -g BOOTDIR="u-boot-${BOARD}"
+	declare -g BOOTSCRIPT=boot-rockchip64-ttyS0.cmd:boot.cmd
+
+	unset family_tweaks_bsp # disable from rockchip64_common
+}

config/boards/rockpi-s.conf

@@ -1,74 +1,42 @@
 # Rockchip RK3308 quad core 256-512MB SoC WiFi
-# https://radaxa.com/products/rockpi/pis
+# https://radxa.com/products/rockpi/pis
+
 BOARD_NAME="Rockpi S"
-BOARDFAMILY="rockchip64"
+BOARDFAMILY=rockchip64
-BOARD_MAINTAINER="brentr"
+BOARD_MAINTAINER=brentr
-BOOTCONFIG="rock-pi-s-rk3308_defconfig"
-BOOT_FDT_FILE="rockchip/rk3308-rock-pi-s.dtb"
 
-DEFAULT_CONSOLE="serial"
+BOOTCONFIG=rock-pi-s-rk3308_defconfig
-SERIALCON="ttyS0"
+BOOT_FDT_FILE=rockchip/rk3308-rock-pi-s.dtb
-KERNEL_TARGET="current,edge"
+
-KERNEL_TEST_TARGET="current"
+KERNEL_TARGET=current,edge
+KERNEL_TEST_TARGET=current
+
+DEFAULT_CONSOLE=serial
+SERIALCON=ttyS0
 MODULES_BLACKLIST="rockchipdrm analogix_dp dw_mipi_dsi dw_hdmi gpu_sched lima hantro_vpu panfrost"
-HAS_VIDEO_OUTPUT="no"
+HAS_VIDEO_OUTPUT=no
-BOOTBRANCH_BOARD="tag:v2022.04"
-BOOTPATCHDIR="u-boot-rockchip64-v2022.04"
 
-OVERLAY_PREFIX='rk3308'
+BOOTBRANCH_BOARD=tag:v2024.10
+BOOTPATCHDIR=v2024.10
+BOOT_SCENARIO=binman
+DDR_BLOB=rk33/rk3308_ddr_589MHz_uart0_m0_v2.07.bin
+BL31_BLOB=rk33/rk3308_bl31_v2.26.elf
 
-#comment out line below for an image that will NOT boot from the built-in SDNAND
+OVERLAY_PREFIX=rk3308
-IDBLOADER_BLOB=$SRC/packages/blobs/rockchip/rk3308_idbloader_ddr589MHz_uart0_m0_v2.06.136sd.bin
 
-#The SDNAND capabilty IDBLOADER_BLOB requires the U-Boot and Linux serial console on UART0
+function post_family_config__rockpis() {
-#Linux will hang on reboot if the console remains on UART2
+	declare -g BOOTDIR="u-boot-${BOARD}"
-
+	declare -g BOOTSCRIPT=boot-rockchip64-ttyS0.cmd:boot.cmd
-#Note:  IDBLOADER_BLOB is derived from
-#  https://dl.radxa.com/rockpis/images/loader/rk3308_loader_ddr589MHz_uart0_m0_v2.06.136sd.bin
-#by using the rkdeveloptool to "upgrade" the previous DDR_BLOB loader on the SDNAND
-#To recreate it, build the image with IDBLOADER_BLOB unset and boot Rock PI-S in MASKROM mode
-#On your host (connected to the RockPi-S's USB-C port):
-#  rdeveloptool db rk3308_loader_ddr589MHz_uart0_m0_v2.06.136sd.bin
-#  rdeveloptool wl 0 newly_built_image.img
-#  rdeveloptool ul rk3308_loader_ddr589MHz_uart0_m0_v2.06.136sd.bin  #this writes 280 sectors
-
-#Then, reset the RockPi-S to boot from SDNAND.  Using that running image:
-#  dd if=/dev/mmcblk0 of=rk3308_idbloader_ddr589MHz_uart0_m0_v2.06.136sd.bin skip=64 count=280
-
-function post_family_config___uboot_config() {
-
-	display_alert "$BOARD" "u-boot ${BOOTBRANCH_BOARD} overrides" "info"
-	unset uboot_custom_postprocess family_tweaks_bsp # disable stuff from rockchip64_common
-
-	BOOTSCRIPT=boot-rockchip64-ttyS0.cmd:boot.cmd
-
-	uboot_custom_postprocess() {
-
-		# TODO: remove this diversion from common caused by different loaderimage params
-		run_host_x86_binary_logged $RKBIN_DIR/tools/loaderimage --pack --uboot ./u-boot-dtb.bin uboot.img 0x600000 --size 1024 1 &&
-			if [ -r "$IDBLOADER_BLOB" ]; then
-				echo "Installing $IDBLOADER_BLOB"
-				echo "Capable of booting from built-in SDNAND"
-				cp $IDBLOADER_BLOB idbloader.bin
-			else
-				[ "$IDBLOADER_BLOB" ] && echo "Missing $IDBLOADER_BLOB"
-				echo "WARNING:  This image will not boot from built-in SDNAND"
-				tools/mkimage -n rk3308 -T rksd -d $RKBIN_DIR/$DDR_BLOB idbloader.bin &&
-					cat $RKBIN_DIR/$MINILOADER_BLOB >> idbloader.bin
-			fi &&
-			run_host_x86_binary_logged $RKBIN_DIR/tools/trust_merger --replace bl31.elf $RKBIN_DIR/$BL31_BLOB trust.ini
-	}
-
-	family_tweaks_bsp() { #Install udev script that derives fixed, unique MAC addresses for net interfaces
 
+	family_tweaks_bsp() { #overrides rockchip64_common.inc
+		#Install udev script that derives fixed, unique MAC addresses for net interfaces
 		#that are assigned random ones -- like RockPI-S's WiFi network interfaces
 		bsp=$SRC/packages/bsp/rockpis
 		rules=etc/udev/rules.d
 
 		install -m 755 $bsp/lib/udev/fixEtherAddr $destination/lib/udev &&
-		install -m 644 $bsp/$rules/05-fixMACaddress.rules $destination/$rules
+			install -m 644 $bsp/$rules/05-fixMACaddress.rules $destination/$rules
 	}
-
 }
 
 function pre_install_kernel_debs__enforce_cma() {
@@ -77,5 +45,5 @@ function pre_install_kernel_debs__enforce_cma() {
 	display_alert "$BOARD" "set CMA size to 16MB due to small DRAM size"
 	run_host_command_logged echo "extraargs=cma=16M" ">>" "${SDCARD}"/boot/armbianEnv.txt
 
-        return 0
+	return 0
 }

config/sources/families/include/rockchip64_common.inc

@@ -56,6 +56,7 @@ esac
 # - tpl-spl-blob: uses mainline u-boot TPL and SPL with proprietary rockchip ATF blob
 # - tpl-blob-atf-mainline: proprietary rockchip ddrbin + mainline u-boot SPL + mainline ATF
 # - blobless: mainline u-boot TPL + mainline u-boot SPL + mainline ATF
+# - binman:  u-boot builds full boot image from information in device tree.  See: https://docs.u-boot.org/en/latest/develop/package/binman.html
 
 #BOOT_SOC=`expr $BOOTCONFIG : '.*\(rk[[:digit:]]\+.*\)_.*'`
 BOOT_SOC=${BOOT_SOC:=$(expr $BOOTCONFIG : '.*\(rk[[:digit:]]\+.*\)_.*' || true)}
@@ -80,12 +81,6 @@ case "$BOOT_SOC" in
 		DDR_BLOB="${DDR_BLOB:-"rk33/rk3308_ddr_589MHz_uart2_m1_v1.30.bin"}"
 		MINILOADER_BLOB="${MINILOADER_BLOB:-"rk33/rk3308_miniloader_v1.22.bin"}"
 		BL31_BLOB="${BL31_BLOB:-"rk33/rk3308_bl31_v2.22.elf"}"
-
-		if [[ ${BRANCH} == legacy ]]; then
-			DDR_BLOB="${DDR_BLOB:-"rk33/rk3308_ddr_589MHz_uart2_m0_v1.26.bin"}"
-			MINILOADER_BLOB="${MINILOADER_BLOB:-"rk33/rk3308_miniloader_sd_nand_v1.13.bin"}"
-			BL31_BLOB="${BL31_BLOB:-"rk33/rk3308_bl31_v2.10.elf"}"
-		fi
 		;;
 
 	rk3328)
@@ -157,9 +152,12 @@ case "$BOOT_SOC" in
 esac
 
 prepare_boot_configuration() {
+	ATFSOURCE=''
+	ATF_COMPILE='no'
 	case "$BOOT_SCENARIO" in
 		blobless | tpl-blob-atf-mainline)
 			UBOOT_TARGET_MAP="BL31=bl31.elf idbloader.img u-boot.itb;;idbloader.img u-boot.itb"
+			ATF_COMPILE=yes
 			ATFSOURCE='https://github.com/ARM-software/arm-trusted-firmware'
 			ATF_COMPILER='aarch64-linux-gnu-'
 			ATFDIR='arm-trusted-firmware'
@@ -171,22 +169,17 @@ prepare_boot_configuration() {
 			[[ $BOOT_SCENARIO == tpl-blob-atf-mainline ]] &&
 				UBOOT_TARGET_MAP="BL31=bl31.elf idbloader.img u-boot.itb;;idbloader.img u-boot.itb"
 			;;
-
 		tpl-spl-blob)
 			UBOOT_TARGET_MAP="BL31=$RKBIN_DIR/$BL31_BLOB idbloader.img u-boot.itb;;idbloader.img u-boot.itb"
-			ATFSOURCE=''
-			ATF_COMPILE='no'
 			;;
 		spl-blobs)
 			UBOOT_TARGET_MAP="BL31=$RKBIN_DIR/$BL31_BLOB spl/u-boot-spl.bin u-boot.dtb u-boot.itb;;idbloader.img u-boot.itb"
-			ATFSOURCE=''
-			ATF_COMPILE='no'
 			;;
-
 		only-blobs)
 			UBOOT_TARGET_MAP="u-boot-dtb.bin;;idbloader.bin uboot.img trust.bin"
-			ATFSOURCE=''
+			;;
-			ATF_COMPILE='no'
+		binman)
+			UBOOT_TARGET_MAP="BL31=$RKBIN_DIR/$BL31_BLOB ROCKCHIP_TPL=$RKBIN_DIR/$DDR_BLOB;;u-boot-rockchip.bin"
 			;;
 	esac
 
@@ -206,45 +199,52 @@ prepare_boot_configuration() {
 }
 
 uboot_custom_postprocess() {
-	[[ -z ${BOOT_SOC} ]] && exit_with_error "BOOT_SOC not defined for scenario '${BOOT_SCENARIO}' for BOARD'=${BOARD}' and BOOTCONFIG='${BOOTCONFIG}'"
+	[[ -z ${BOOT_SOC} ]] &&
+		exit_with_error "BOOT_SOC not defined for scenario '${BOOT_SCENARIO}' for BOARD'=${BOARD}' and BOOTCONFIG='${BOOTCONFIG}'"
+	display_alert "${BOARD}" "boots with ${BOOT_SCENARIO} scenario" "info"
 
-	if [[ $BOOT_SCENARIO == "blobless" || $BOOT_SCENARIO == "tpl-spl-blob" ]]; then
+	case "$BOOT_SCENARIO" in
-		:
+		blobless | tpl-spl-blob | binman)
-	elif [[ $BOOT_SCENARIO == "spl-blobs" || $BOOT_SCENARIO == "tpl-blob-atf-mainline" ]]; then
+			:
-		# Bomb if DDR_BLOB not defined or does not exist
+			;;
-		declare SPL_BIN_PATH="${RKBIN_DIR}/${DDR_BLOB}"
-		[[ -z ${SPL_BIN_PATH} ]] && exit_with_error "DDR_BLOB not defined for scenario ${BOOT_SCENARIO}"
-		[[ ! -f "${SPL_BIN_PATH}" ]] && exit_with_error "DDR_BLOB ${SPL_BIN_PATH} does not exist for scenario ${BOOT_SCENARIO}"
 
-		if [[ $BOOT_SOC == "rk3576" ]]; then
+		spl-blobs | tpl-blob-atf-mainline)
-			display_alert "boot_merger for '${BOOT_SOC}' for scenario ${BOOT_SCENARIO}" "SPL_BIN_PATH: ${SPL_BIN_PATH}" "debug"
+			# Bomb if DDR_BLOB not defined or does not exist
-			RKBOOT_INI_FILE=rk3576.ini
+			declare SPL_BIN_PATH="${RKBIN_DIR}/${DDR_BLOB}"
-			cp $RKBIN_DIR/rk35/RK3576MINIALL.ini $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
+			[[ -z ${SPL_BIN_PATH} ]] && exit_with_error "DDR_BLOB not defined for scenario ${BOOT_SCENARIO}"
-			sed -i "s|FlashBoost=.*$|FlashBoost=${RKBIN_DIR}/rk35/rk3576_boost_v1.02.bin|g" $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
+			[[ ! -f "${SPL_BIN_PATH}" ]] && exit_with_error "DDR_BLOB ${SPL_BIN_PATH} does not exist for scenario ${BOOT_SCENARIO}"
-			sed -i "s|Path1=.*rk3576_ddr.*$|Path1=${SPL_BIN_PATH}|g" $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
-			sed -i "s|Path1=.*rk3576_usbplug.*$|Path1=${RKBIN_DIR}/rk35/rk3576_usbplug_v1.03.bin|g" $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
-			sed -i "s|FlashData=.*$|FlashData=${SPL_BIN_PATH}|g" $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
-			sed -i "s|FlashBoot=.*$|FlashBoot=./spl/u-boot-spl.bin|g" $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
-			sed -i "s|IDB_PATH=.*$|IDB_PATH=idbloader.img|g" $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
-			run_host_x86_binary_logged $RKBIN_DIR/tools/boot_merger $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
-			rm -f $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
-		else
-			display_alert "mkimage for '${BOOT_SOC}' for scenario ${BOOT_SCENARIO}" "SPL_BIN_PATH: ${SPL_BIN_PATH}" "debug"
-			run_host_command_logged tools/mkimage -n "${BOOT_SOC_MKIMAGE}" -T rksd -d "${SPL_BIN_PATH}:spl/u-boot-spl.bin" idbloader.img
-		fi
 
-	elif [[ $BOOT_SCENARIO == "only-blobs" ]]; then
+			if [[ "$BOOT_SOC" == "rk3576" ]]; then
+				display_alert "boot_merger for '${BOOT_SOC}' for scenario ${BOOT_SCENARIO}" "SPL_BIN_PATH: ${SPL_BIN_PATH}" "debug"
+				RKBOOT_INI_FILE=rk3576.ini
+				cp $RKBIN_DIR/rk35/RK3576MINIALL.ini $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
+				sed -i "s|FlashBoost=.*$|FlashBoost=${RKBIN_DIR}/rk35/rk3576_boost_v1.02.bin|g" $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
+				sed -i "s|Path1=.*rk3576_ddr.*$|Path1=${SPL_BIN_PATH}|g" $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
+				sed -i "s|Path1=.*rk3576_usbplug.*$|Path1=${RKBIN_DIR}/rk35/rk3576_usbplug_v1.03.bin|g" $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
+				sed -i "s|FlashData=.*$|FlashData=${SPL_BIN_PATH}|g" $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
+				sed -i "s|FlashBoot=.*$|FlashBoot=./spl/u-boot-spl.bin|g" $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
+				sed -i "s|IDB_PATH=.*$|IDB_PATH=idbloader.img|g" $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
+				run_host_x86_binary_logged $RKBIN_DIR/tools/boot_merger $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
+				rm -f $RKBOOT_INI_FILE
+			else
+				display_alert "mkimage for '${BOOT_SOC}' for scenario ${BOOT_SCENARIO}" "SPL_BIN_PATH: ${SPL_BIN_PATH}" "debug"
+				run_host_command_logged tools/mkimage -n "${BOOT_SOC_MKIMAGE}" -T rksd -d "${SPL_BIN_PATH}:spl/u-boot-spl.bin" idbloader.img
+			fi
+			;;
 
-		local tempfile
+		only-blobs)
-		tempfile=$(mktemp)
+			local tempfile
-		run_host_command_logged tools/mkimage -n "${BOOT_SOC_MKIMAGE}" -T rksd -d $RKBIN_DIR/$DDR_BLOB idbloader.bin
+			tempfile=$(mktemp)
-		cat $RKBIN_DIR/$MINILOADER_BLOB >> idbloader.bin
+			run_host_command_logged tools/mkimage -n "${BOOT_SOC_MKIMAGE}" -T rksd -d $RKBIN_DIR/$DDR_BLOB idbloader.bin
-		run_host_x86_binary_logged $RKBIN_DIR/tools/loaderimage --pack --uboot ./u-boot-dtb.bin uboot.img 0x200000
+			cat $RKBIN_DIR/$MINILOADER_BLOB >> idbloader.bin
-		run_host_x86_binary_logged $RKBIN_DIR/tools/trust_merger --replace bl31.elf $RKBIN_DIR/$BL31_BLOB trust.ini
+			run_host_x86_binary_logged $RKBIN_DIR/tools/loaderimage --pack --uboot ./u-boot-dtb.bin uboot.img 0x200000
+			run_host_x86_binary_logged $RKBIN_DIR/tools/trust_merger --replace bl31.elf $RKBIN_DIR/$BL31_BLOB trust.ini
+			;;
 
-	else
+		*)
-		exit_with_error "Unsupported u-boot processing configuration!"
+			exit_with_error "\"$BOOT_SCENARIO\" is an Unsupported Boot Scenario!"
-	fi
+			;;
+	esac
 
 	if [[ $BOOT_SUPPORT_SPI == yes ]]; then
 		if [[ "${BOOT_SPI_RKSPI_LOADER:-"no"}" == "yes" ]]; then
@@ -273,9 +273,11 @@ write_uboot_platform() {
 	local logging_prelude=""
 	[[ $(type -t run_host_command_logged) == function ]] && logging_prelude="run_host_command_logged"
 
-	if [[ -f $1/rksd_loader.img ]]; then # legacy rk3399 loader
+	if [ -f $1/u-boot-rockchip.bin ]; then #"$BOOT_SCENARIO" == binman
+		${logging_prelude} dd if=$1/u-boot-rockchip.bin of=$2 bs=32k seek=1 conv=notrunc status=none
+	elif [ -f $1/rksd_loader.img ]; then # legacy rk3399 loader
 		${logging_prelude} dd if=$1/rksd_loader.img of=$2 seek=64 conv=notrunc status=none
-	elif [[ -f $1/u-boot.itb ]]; then # $BOOT_SCENARIO == "blobless" || $BOOT_SCENARIO == "tpl-spl-blob"
+	elif [[ -f $1/u-boot.itb ]]; then # $BOOT_SCENARIO "blobless" or "tpl-spl-blob"
 		${logging_prelude} dd if=$1/idbloader.img of=$2 seek=64 conv=notrunc status=none
 		${logging_prelude} dd if=$1/u-boot.itb of=$2 seek=16384 conv=notrunc status=none
 	elif [[ -f $1/uboot.img ]]; then # $BOOT_SCENARIO == "only-blobs"
@@ -288,16 +290,13 @@ write_uboot_platform() {
 	fi
 }
 
+# @TODO: this is not ready for BOOT_SCENARIO=binman yet
 write_uboot_platform_mtd() {
 	if [[ -f $1/rkspi_loader.img ]]; then
-
 		dd if=$1/rkspi_loader.img of=$2 conv=notrunc status=none > /dev/null 2>&1
-
 	else
-
 		echo "SPI u-boot image not found!"
 		exit 1
-
 	fi
 }
 

patch/u-boot/v2024.10/board_rock-s0/1120-mmcBootOnRockS0v1-1.patch

@@ -0,0 +1,42 @@
+From 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
+From: Brent Roman <genosenosor@gmail.com>
+Date: Sat, 16 Nov 2024 20:50:41 -0800
+Subject: Ensure Rock S0 v1.1 boards u-boot SPL can access MMC card
+
+Signed-off-by: Brent Roman <genosenosor@gmail.com>
+---
+ arch/arm/dts/rk3308-rock-s0-u-boot.dtsi | 15 ++++++++++
+ 1 file changed, 15 insertions(+)
+
+diff --git a/arch/arm/dts/rk3308-rock-s0-u-boot.dtsi b/arch/arm/dts/rk3308-rock-s0-u-boot.dtsi
+index 84ca2ee0d5..c0d7f7b651 100644
+--- a/arch/arm/dts/rk3308-rock-s0-u-boot.dtsi
++++ b/arch/arm/dts/rk3308-rock-s0-u-boot.dtsi
+@@ -5,10 +5,25 @@
+ &emmc_pwren {
+ 	bootph-pre-ram;
+ 	bootph-some-ram;
+ };
+ 
++&pcfg_pull_down {
++	bootph-pre-ram;
++	bootph-some-ram;
++};
++
++&sdmmc {
++	pinctrl-0 = <&sdmmc_clk &sdmmc_cmd &sdmmc_det &sdmmc_pwren &sdmmc_bus4>;
++};
++
++&sdmmc_pwren {
++	bootph-pre-ram;
++	bootph-some-ram;
++	rockchip,pins = <4 RK_PD6 0 &pcfg_pull_down>;
++};
++
+ &uart0 {
+ 	bootph-all;
+ 	clock-frequency = <24000000>;
+ };
+ 
+-- 
+Created with Armbian build tools https://github.com/armbian/build